Top

20 Million DirecTV PVRs (and Nothing On)

June 16, 2005

Slate has an article up about Rupert Murduch trying to displace the video rental market by providing PVRs to 20 million DirecTV customers. (via PVRBlog)

Murdoch is attempting to revolutionize the world’s video-rental market (both VHS and DVD). Since its inception in the late 1970s, video renting has been an inefficient business. Indeed, on first hearing the business model, Warner Bros. titan Steve Ross asked incredulously, “Can we really expect millions of busy people to get in their car, drive to a store, pick out a movie, stand in line, fill out a rental agreement, pay a deposit, drive home, play it on their VCR and then, the next day, repeat the procedure in reverse to return it?” Even with improvements in swiping credit cards and mail-in schemes such as Netflix, renting remains a cumbersome affair.

Murdoch plans to digitally deliver movies and other programming from his satellites to home digital video recorders that would be the same quality, or higher (HDTV), than a DVD. Since there are not enough transponders on satellites to stream movies to individual subscribers on demand, Murdoch needs DVRs in every home to make his digital-delivery system work. With DVRs, the satellites can upload movies in the middle of the night in encrypted form onto subscribers’ hard discs without us having to do anything or even be aware of it. (One idea now under consideration at DirecTV is to provide these DVRs with an enormous 160-gigabyte recording capacity. The subscriber would only be told about 80 gigabytes, with the remaining 80 gigabytes reserved for encrypted movies.) Once the movies are placed on the DVRs, a customer “rents” them by clicking on his remote control.

A bold plan indeed, and it could probably play hell with the top ten rentals on the “recently arrived” rack at the local Blockbuster.

The problem is that 160 gig just isn’t that enormous.

Assuming that the content is encoded at a typical satellite-TV rate, it’s going to be hard fitting more than 20 or so movies in that “hidden” 80 gig stash.

Unfortunately, what this doesn’t let you take advantage of is “The Long Tail“.

“Long Tail” economics lets companies like Netflix take advantage of almost non-existent inventory costs (compared to brick and mortor stores, or even 80 gig of satellite-delivered VOD content) to make considerably more money on the vast selection of “seldom rented” titles they carry than the current most popular rentals.

As we teeter on the brink of seeing enough bandwidth to make internet delivery of movies practical, owning a big piece of the “top ten” rental market just might not be that great of a competitive position…

Like this article? Share it!
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon

Comments

Got something to say? [privacy policy]





Possibly Related


Wal-Mart Has Left The Building (to Netflix)Apparently Wal-Mart has thrown in the towel on online movie rentals, and is directing their customers to Netflix. Wal-Mart Stores Inc. and Netflix Inc., rivals in online movie rentals, made an agreement in which Wal- Mart ends its rental business in exchange for Netflix promoting its DVD movie sales. Netflix shares soared as much as 24 percent. With rumors floating that Blockbuster is looking to raise their rates $3 a month (or depart the online rental scene altogether), and that Amazon is considering a partnership with Netflix, this has been quite the banner week for the Los Gatos, CA based company. Of course, this is still all liable to be short-lived. Every time broadband speeds climb up a notch, the...


HD PVRs - Rock and Hard PlaceThomas Hawk has some comments on my Dish 942 article. Thomas writes: These type of HDTV PVRs will be the competition for TiVo and Media Center going forward. It will be important that TiVo and Media Center are able to distinguish themselves in the HDTV PVR space in order to convince people that it is worth spending the money over what you can get for free (kinda free anyway) from your cable or satellite provider. Absolutely -- and there's the rub. HD sources come in three forms today -- broadcast, cable, and satellite. For broadcast, you can get your local channels, unencrypted. Cable and Satellite come with their own encryption on board, and by and large, there's no way to...


Netflix Parties after Blockbuster ElectionBlockbuster's largest shareholder was elected to their board yesterday amid vows to curtail spending. Analyst's guess as to the first target for cuts? Their online rental program, where they're throwing money at trying to catch Netflix. Netflix stock rose 9 percent after the vote, according to Reuters. "Netflix investors are saying, 'Obviously Blockbuster is going to abandon online," Wedbush Morgan Securities analyst Michael Pachter said. "It's not that obvious. Icahn is not in charge -- he has three out of seven votes." Blockbuster is locked in an expensive price war with Netflix over online subscribers. Blockbuster launched its online service in August at a cost of $50 million, and said it would spend about $120 million this year as part...


Apple TV - A Year in the Life Being the unreconstructed Apple fanboy that I am, this month makes it officially one year that I've lived with an Apple TV -- and it's been an interesting year. Unlike some folks, I liked the Apple TV straight out of the box. The form factor (basically a half-height Mac Mini) was nice, it took five minutes to hook up to my home media system, and another five minutes to set up. Functionality wise, it was nice -- jacked into my surround sound system, it made a dandy player for my iTunes playlists, along with nice animations of images from iPhoto. Even better, it made a reasonable and useful tool for watching video podcasts, something I seldom do at my...


Lack of HD & multiple tuners killing Tivo?Reuters reports on a new study that claims Tivo is rapidly losing mindshare... Brandimensions, the research firm that conducted the study, said that TiVo's standalone set-top box is failing in two areas: its inability to record two shows simultaneously and to play back shows in high-definition TV quality. "This may not sound like a big deal," wrote one TiVo user about the latter, "but after watching 'Lost' or 'The Sopranos' on HD, there is no going back." Can we have an "amen" from the congregation? Providing multiple tuners is a big deal, with networks constantly scheduling leading shows against each other. That was one of the best reasons to have a (dual tuner) DirecTivo back in the day, and I've...

Bottom