Top

First Impressions of iTunes 5

September 11, 2005

Now that I finally got the silly thing installed, I’ve had a little time to play with it…

Some first impressions –

Damn this thing is ugly. Burnt Aqua Unified? Were these corners done with pinking shears? It just all looks… Ummm… Out of place. Oh well. Looks ain’t everything (if they were, I’d probably never have another date.)


Did it actually get slower? I haven’t tried to do any benchmarks yet, but just as a subjective impression, importing a few new tunes, listening and cleaning up ID3 tags, I saw more beachballs than in a trip to the sporting goods store; nothing else was running but a web browser and a mail client…

Dear Apple — if it’s going to be next summer or next fall before we get PowerBooks with more horsepower than a G4, you’ve got to promise not to make basic parts of the system (hey, listening to tunes while I work is basic to me) worse performance hogs than they already are in the meantime…

On the up-side…

Folders for playlists. Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! I’ve needed this for a looong time…

Make any audio file bookmarkable — excellent! I was getting tired of converting spoken word stuff to AAC and running an AppleScript just to be able to pick up where I left off.

Skip this file during shuffle — This will simplify my playlists a lot.

Smart Shuffle — I wonder how we’ll know if this thing actually does something? iTunes — and particularly the iPod — seem to get into very weird moods with shuffle sometimes, running through strings of back-to-back same artist play; other times you couldn’t make it happen on a bet… It’d almost be funny if this was just a slider that didn’t do anything other than launch more long debates about random play behavior…

I’ve got mixed emotions about the reorganization of Preferences — it probably makes more sense this way, but I know people who’ve been using the old layout for several years who just figured it out, and now they’re going to be completely lost again…

Like this article? Share it!
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon

Comments

Got something to say? [privacy policy]





Possibly Related


Smarter iTunes PlaylistsIf you're an iTunes user (Windows or Mac either one), MacWorld has some good tips on enhancing your experience by building smarter playlists. There are also some great ideas on getting the most out of your playlists for various iPod flavors, including older iPods and the iPod Shuffle....


Kindle First Impressions My Kindle arrived last night, and I've had just enough time with it to form some early impressions. Physical Yes, the thing is butt ugly. It badly needs a pass through Apple's industrial design group. Or even Dell's. But that's okay, it's early days, and you buy it to read ebooks, not look cool. That's why you have the iPhone. I'm a little more concerned about the build quality -- the buttons, particularly the Previous/Next/Back paddle buttons, feel a little fragile. I'm not sure if they are, but I'm a little nervous about how many times I'm going to click them before they stop responding. Worse, you can't avoid the things. Between the big navigation buttons, and the keyboard,...


Apple TV Initial ImpressionsSomething bad happened yesterday -- I wore out yet another keyboard. Worse, while I was at the crack store Fry's picking up a new one, I walked past a stack of Apple TVs, and one of them followed me home. Outside of being in the store anyway for the keyboard thing (the "colon" key failed -- how the hell can a "colon" key fail? Semicolon works. Shift+anything else works. Try writing HTML or CSS without a colon key), I probably wouldn't have been as tempted to get one right now if it hadn't been for the high rate of very interesting hacks emerging for the Apple TV over the past few days -- I'm guessing Apple has hit another one...


iTunes for Treo (sorta)Tea Vui Huang's Mass Storage Synchronizer will let you synchronize an iTunes playlist with your Treo, where you can play your music with your favorite Treo MP3 player. The page is written towards use with the Sony Ericsson Walkman phones, but he also includes a Treo version of the program, which appears to be a recent development. Audio file types supported: MP3 MP4 M4A 3GP (Audio encoded in AAC or AMR) AMR WAV G-MIDI Only for Windows so far, unfortunately......


Killer iTunes Add-OnsiPodlounge has a an article on "iTunes Extreme - Killer Add-ons". They cover lots of visualization stuff, which is great if you like that sort of thing, plus a good handful of other plug-ins for Windows and OS X. After reading this, I gave Octiv's VolumeLogic another try, and it does sound great, but it eats up a bit too much CPU performance for my taste... Oh well... They did miss a few of my OS X freeware favorites: SizzlingKeys - lets you pause and control next/prev/volume with hotkeys. Make Bookmarkable - A script to make your AAC encoded files bookmarkable -- in other words, they'll resume playing where you last stopped in iTunes or on an iPod. A good...

Bottom